I recently wrote the following sentence as a practice exercise:

We can sleep on the floor.
Мы можем спать на по́ле.

After writing it, I learned that "по́ле" should be "полу́" and that "полу́" is in the locative case. I had already done some reading on the locative case previously, but clearly I need more practice before I consistently and accurately assess the need for it. Be that as it may, it made me take a look at all the cases that the word "пол" can take. In the process, I learned that not all nouns have a need for a locative case. For example, "по́ле" (field) does not appear to have a locative case.

Is there a list of nouns that do take the locative case? And is there any rhyme or reason to it? I ask this because if there is any sort of pattern to it, why would something like a "floor" need locative case, but not a "field?" If anyone happens to have either a list of nouns with a locative case or know of some sort of rule that helps one identify the types of nouns that would require it, what a helpful resource that would be.

Another thing I noticed, however, is that "пол" has a prepositional case, something I am assuming all Russian nouns have. (If there are any that do not, please enlighten me.) The thing is, I cannot come up with an example of when it would be used and all the examples I've seen of the prepositional case for "по́ле" are clearly referring to a "field" and not a "floor." Is there ever a time when one uses по́ле to refer to the floor? And if so, could you provide some examples?

  • 2
    ru.wiktionary.org/wiki/… – Quassnoi Jul 25 '17 at 22:01
  • @Quassnoi - that worth to be an answer. See also Locative case - Местный падеж. There seem to be no rhyme or reason for locative case. It seems to be a relic of Proto-Slavic language. – Alexander Jul 25 '17 at 23:19
  • I just checked out your link. What a great resource! I concur with Alexander in that it could suffice as an answer, but still I would like to know if "по́ле" (as a prepositional case of "пол") "ever refers to a "floor," and if examples could be provided, even better. I'll leave this question open for a bit to see if that can't be answered, but if not, I definitely think I'd give Quassnoi's link in an answer post the green checkmark. Oh but nevermind, I see he has already done so. Once again, ,болбшое спасибоб, Quassnoi. – Lisa Beck Jul 26 '17 at 3:10
  • @Alexander: all nouns with locative are either declension II male or declension III, but aside from this no rhyme or reason indeed – Quassnoi Jul 26 '17 at 9:03

Sure, with any preposition except в or на:

  • … богатым было и внутреннее убранство церкви: старики упоминали о паркетном поле и хрустальном паникадиле

  • При наливном поле она (демпферная лента) устанавливается с целью компенсировать расширения бетона при нагреве, чтобы избежать его растрескивания.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.