The ending -ить does not tell you much about how a verb is conjugated. As you've seen, verbs ending in -ить can be conjugated differently. Let me throw in:
- люби́ть - люблю́
- жить - живу́
Note that бре́ю and гнию́ also differ in emphasis.
Moreover, verbs that are conjugated similarly, can have different infinitives:
- брею, бреешь, бреет, INFINITIVE: брить
- грею, греешь, греет, INFINITIVE: греть
Your best bet is to consult a dictionary; e.g. the Russian Wiktionary has conjugation tables for most verbs. As you learn more verbs, you'll learn which ones are conjugated similarly:
- бить, пить, лить - бью, пью, лью,
- любить - люблю, копить - коплю, etc
Andrey Zalizniak's Grammatical Dictionary of Russian lists 16 conjugation classes, but even those are not comprehensive: some verbs have their own distinct conjugation, e.g. мыть - мо́ю, плыть - плыву́, моло́ть - мелю́ and many others.