4

I read in Pushkin's Дружба the word "легкий", an adjective meaning "slight". There's even an interesting thread on Russian S.E. about the modern pronouciation of the word.

I noticed two ways to write it : either легкий (as Puskin did) either лёгкий as modern dictionaries do.

Hence my questions :

(1) which phonological/orthographic shift explains both spellings ? I can't see anything helpfull in the Wikipedia article dedicated to the reforms of Russian orthography.

(2) how was the word was pronounced at Pushkin's times ?

2
  • 3
    It's a common issue omitting "umlaut" over "Ё" letter. Although this is thought to be an error yet everyone does this ten times a day. No spelling is shifted. – Matt Jul 8 '15 at 6:25
  • 3
    @user4419802 This is not an error. In many dictionaries words that differ only in "ё/е" are listed as if there is no difference in them: "Слова на букву ё сортируются так же, как если бы они были на букву е, но при этом если слова различаются только на е — ё, то слово на ё ставится после. Такой порядок принят в подавляющем большинстве печатных словарей и энциклопедий." Also there is no need to disambiguate two words (небо/нёбо) as only word лёгкий exists. – Artemix Jul 9 '15 at 7:41
11

Letter ё is optional, it is usually replaced by е. We have a number of questions about this letter on this site, for example: Using written е instead of ë, Is 'ё' a distinct letter, or is it just 'е' with a diaeresis?, What are all the times where "е" changes to "ё"?. In short, letter ё is always used only in dictionaries, text for beginners and children, uncommon foreign words (like geographical names) and in cases when difference between word with ё and е is not obvious from the context (like небо (sky) and нёбо (roof of mouth)).

For modern reader it is definitely лёгкий. As for Pushkin times - I'm not sure what was the pronunciation at those times. Usually you notice the difference when two words stand at the end of the verse and should be rhymed (like Ольга/фольга pair which currently have different stresses, but at the beginning of the XX century both words had a stress on a first syllable).

But even when two words happen at the end of a poem's line, it is hard to tell should those words be pronounced with ё or with е. A long article about letter ё has the following example (by academic Vinogradov) of Pushkin's Poltava:

Тесним мы шведов рать за ратью;
Темнеет слава их знамен,
И бога брани благодатью
Наш каждый шаг запечатлен?

According to Vinogradov here both words are likely using "е" (знамен/запечатлен), but we cannot tell for sure.

Another example where there is е and not ё is verses from Krylov's fable "Лебедь, Щука и Рак" (example from Wikipedia article):

Когда в товарищах согласья нет —
На лад их дело не пойдет

Here, in Krylov's times пойдет was pronounced as е as can be seen from the rhymed нет/пойдет. Interestingly, in modern textbook for pupils пойдет in this verse is written using ё: пойдёт.


Looks like it was pronounced as легкий in Pushkin times. According to Wikipedia article the letter ё's was printed for a first time in 1795. Before that time a number of letter combinations served to resemble this sound (о, ьо, їô, ió, ио). However Google Books has a book printed in 1792, which is entitled "Новый легкий и самый безопасый способ лѣчения чесотки". If it has to be pronounced as ё there should be one of this combinations used: о, ьо, їô, ió, ио. Since it is not so, it has to be read as "е".

3
  • Thank you very much : the links you give are very usefull. – suizokukan Jul 8 '15 at 9:24
  • 1
    On the last paragraph: no, orthography with e was enforced by some people when the reading has long been ['о]. There's a guy (forgot the name) who even explicitly writes in XVIII century: "We do say in casual speech: Пьотр, Иван, идите сюда, but we should write Петр". – Viridianus Dec 12 '20 at 16:03
  • Or, the poets could make use of archaic pronunciation for the sake of rhyme. – Anixx Apr 9 at 12:21

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.