7

When should твоих be used and when should своих be used?

What are the reasons for picking one over the other?

3
  • твоих is yours, своих is mine - what exactly are you asking about?
    – shabunc
    Sep 4, 2012 at 14:22
  • @shabunc "Не ешь мои апельсины, тебе что, своих мало?"
    – Olga
    Sep 4, 2012 at 14:28
  • @Olga, oh, in that sense. Well, it looks like this is a very nice question, but it better be edited to be more precise.
    – shabunc
    Sep 4, 2012 at 14:36

4 Answers 4

6

I think that the difference is the following:

"мой, твой, его (её, их)" denote "belonging to the speaker, the addressee, a third person" respectively.

"свой" is used when you want to denote "belonging to the subject of the sentence".

If the subject of the sentence is the 1st or 2nd person pronoun, "свой" is preferred. In other cases, "мой", "твой", "его (её, их)" is used. This is not a strict rule, though.

Examples:

Я стираю свои штаны - I'm washing my pants. ("мои штаны" is also possible)
Я стираю твои штаны - I'm washing your pants. ("свои штаны" is not possible, it would mean "my pants" in this sentence).

If the subject is a quantification pronoun, than "свой" is the only option.

Каждый стирает свои штаны - Everyone is washing their (own) pants. ("его" is not possible)

Please note that the subject is not always a noun in nominative case, it is a more complex notion. It also includes:

  • null subjects of imperative clauses, as in "постирай свои штаны" - "wash your pants"
  • dative subjects, as in "тебе пора постирать свои штаны" - "it's time for you to wash your pants"

If the sentence is imperative, "свой" is the only option.

Постирай свои штаны - Wash your pants. ("твои" is not possible, at least for me)

3
  • I believe it's not (necessarily) a subject but rather the last mentioned (or implied) actant: мама велела Маше убрать свои игрушки.
    – Quassnoi
    Sep 4, 2012 at 17:54
  • 3
    it's not clear whose toys "свои" is referring to (can be both of them) Sep 4, 2012 at 18:20
  • @Quassnoi In your example there are 2 verbs, 2 subjects and 2 readings. "Мама передала Маше свои игрушки" has only one possible meaning
    – Olga
    Sep 4, 2012 at 22:33
3

I do believe that Olga gave a succinct and accurate explanation. I just want to add that actually there are cases where свой is completely interchangeable with мой, твой etc.

Let's, once again, refer to our Bible )

Возможно синонимическое употребление притяжательных местоимений мой – свой, твой – свой и т.п. Ср.: ... Я предаюсь моим мечтам (Пушкин). – Я не потерплю в своем доме воров (Чехов). Употребление притяжательных местоимений мой, твой, наш, ваш вместо возможного по условиям контекста свой больше подчеркивает связь с соответствующим лицом, в частности при противопоставлении, например: Моей главы коснись твоей рукой (Жуковский).

Д. Э. Розенталь, "Литературное редактирование текста", "Возвратные и притяжательные местоимения".

To translate, this pronouns can be synonymous, especially when we can suspect a logical opposition - Touch my head with your hand.

1

твоих = of your ones

своих = of oneself's ones

0

Не ешь мои апельсины, тебе что своих мало? = Не ешь мои апельсины, тебе что твоих мало?

I'm not a philologist, but I think in this case both options are equal

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.